Featured image of post Comparing WebUI Testing approaches

Comparing WebUI Testing approaches

Comparison of Selenium, Cypress, Puppeteer, TestCafe, WebDriverIO, and Katalon

What is UI Testing and Automated Test Generation?

UI Testing

UI testing simulates real user interactions, such as:

  • Clicking buttons
  • Filling out forms
  • Navigating through pages
  • Checking if elements exist and are visible

Automated UI Testing

Rather than manually clicking through a website, UI testing tools automate interactions using scripts that run in a browser.


Framework Comparison Table

FrameworkPrimary LanguageHeadless Mode?Cross-Browser?Open Source?Specialty
SeleniumJava, Python, C#YesYesYesMost widely used automation tool
CypressJavaScriptYesNo (Chromium-based only)YesFast and developer-friendly
PuppeteerJavaScriptYesNo (Chrome & Firefox)YesGreat for headless Chrome automation
TestCafeJavaScriptYesYesYesNo WebDriver dependency
WebDriverIOJavaScriptYesYesYesWebDriver-based automation for Node.js
KatalonJava, GroovyYesYesNo (Freemium)User-friendly tool with built-in reporting

Code Examples for Each Tool

Selenium – Classic UI Automation

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
from selenium import webdriver

driver = webdriver.Chrome()
driver.get("https://example.com")

button = driver.find_element("id", "submit-button")
button.click()

Cypress – Fast and Reliable Testing

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
describe("Login Test", () => {
  it("should log in successfully", () => {
    cy.visit("https://example.com");
    cy.get("#username").type("admin");
    cy.get("#password").type("password");
    cy.get("#login-button").click();
    cy.contains("Welcome, admin!");
  });
});

Puppeteer – Headless Chrome Automation

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
const puppeteer = require("puppeteer");

(async () => {
  const browser = await puppeteer.launch();
  const page = await browser.newPage();
  await page.goto("https://example.com");
  await page.click("#submit-button");
  await browser.close();
})();

TestCafe – Easy to Use UI Testing

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
import { Selector } from "testcafe";

fixture("Login Test").page("https://example.com");

test("Login successfully", async (t) => {
  await t.typeText("#username", "admin")
        .typeText("#password", "password")
        .click("#login-button")
        .expect(Selector("#welcome-message").innerText)
        .contains("Welcome, admin!");
});

WebDriverIO – WebDriver-Based Automation

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
describe("Login Test", () => {
  it("should log in successfully", async () => {
    await browser.url("https://example.com");
    await $("#username").setValue("admin");
    await $("#password").setValue("password");
    await $("#login-button").click();
    await expect($("#welcome-message")).toHaveTextContaining("Welcome, admin!");
  });
});

Katalon – UI Automation with Recording

1
2
3
4
WebUI.openBrowser("https://example.com");
WebUI.setText(findTestObject("input_Username"), "admin");
WebUI.setText(findTestObject("input_Password"), "password");
WebUI.click(findTestObject("button_Login"));

Pros and Cons of Each Tool

ToolProsCons
SeleniumMost widely supportedSlower than newer tools
CypressFast execution, great DXOnly supports Chromium
PuppeteerGreat for headless ChromeNo Safari support
TestCafeNo WebDriver dependencySmaller community
WebDriverIOFull WebDriver supportRequires more setup
KatalonBuilt-in recording, reportsPaid features

Key Ideas

  • Selenium is the oldest and most widely supported UI testing tool.
  • Cypress is great for fast, developer-friendly testing but is limited to Chromium.
  • Puppeteer is perfect for headless Chrome automation.
  • TestCafe is simpler to set up since it doesn’t require WebDriver.
  • WebDriverIO integrates well with Node.js automation workflows.
  • Katalon provides built-in recording and reporting for teams.

References

  1. Selenium Documentation
  2. Cypress Docs
  3. Playwright Docs
  4. Puppeteer Docs
  5. TestCafe Docs
  6. WebDriverIO Docs
  7. Katalon Docs